5-Year FHA Mortgages vs. 30-Year FHA Mortgages

Interest rates and payments can change with a five-year FHA loan.
i Comstock/Comstock/Getty Images

Mortgage insurance offered by the Federal Housing Administration can remove many of the obstacles to home ownership. This insurance protects a lender from losing money if you fail to pay on a loan. With FHA mortgage insurance, you only have to front a small amount, as low as 3.5 percent of the price of the home. The Federal Housing Administration insures 30-year, fixed-rate mortgages and certain adjustable-rate mortgages, such as those whose rates start changing after the first five years. Choosing whether to go with the five-year adjustable loan or the 30-year fixed loan depends upon how much certainty you want in your budget, how much house you want and what you can pay on a mortgage.

Interest Rates

The interest rate in a five-year FHA loan stays the same for the first five years. Starting in year six, the rate moves up or down with an index based upon the interest a person would get from owning U.S. Treasury Securities. The Federal Housing Administration limits annual increases to two percentage points and increases through the loan's life to six percentage points. This means that if you took out the loan at four percent, you pay four percent interest for the first 60 months. Afterwards, your interest rate can never jump above 10 percent as long as you have the loan. With a 30-year FHA loan, your interest rate never changes.

Monthly Payments

The 30-year FHA mortgage brings you certainty. Because rates do not change, your monthly principal and interest payments stay constant. Changes in property taxes and mortgage insurance costs might move your monthly mortgage payments slightly. Planning your budget proves somewhat more challenging with a five-year mortgage. After five years, you don't know what the interest rate will be or what you'll pay each month. If rates go up, you'll have higher mortgage payments, which means less money for vacations, buying a new car, keeping up your home or paying off other debt. However, because FHA caps interest rate rises each year and over the life of the loan, a five-year FHA mortgage will not take you on a roller coaster ride.

Purchasing Power

You might get more house with a five-year FHA loan than a 30-year loan. What you can borrow depends upon the mortgage payment, your other debt and your income before taxes. FHA limits your mortgage payment to 31 percent of your gross income; your mortgage payment plus your other debts cannot top 43 percent of your gross income. According to the National Foundation for Consumer Counseling, adjustable rate mortgages allow for larger loans because the initial rates are lower than fixed-rate mortgages. You get a smaller loan with a 30-year FHA loan because your monthly mortgage payments are higher.

Choosing the Better Alternative

Take the five-year FHA loan if you plan to refinance or move after five years in the home. Since rates and payments can go up after five years, consider whether you think you'll have more money because of a higher-paying job, profits from selling property or an inheritance. If you are not confident your income will rise, opt for the fixed mortgage rather than plunging into the adjustable rate.

the nest